Pavano addition makes Twins roster situation more clear

Ladies and gentlemen … they got the ‘stache.

The Minnesota Twins agreed to a two-year, $16.5 million contract with startng pitcher Carl Pavano on Wednesday. His return gives the Twins a stable, veteran starting pitcher on a rotation that has quite a bit of instability and youth.

I like this move from the Twins perspective. Makes a lot more financial sense than giving Matt Capps a deal that pays him more than $7 million to pitch 60 or 70 innings when they could have afforded to keep both Matt Guerrier and Jesse Crain with that money, but we’ll leave it there.

Let’s take a look at the roster:

  • Starting pitching: Carl Pavano, Francisco Liriano, Scott Baker, Brian Duensing are probably in. Kevin Slowey and Nick Blackburn battle for final spot, with loser probably ending up as Twins long reliever. Kyle Gibson will be waiting in the minors if anyone fails.
  • Bullpen: Joe Nathan will close if he’s healthy, with Matt Capps and Jose Mijares serving as primary set-up men. Loser of Blackburn/Slowey rotation battle will end up in bullpen. Eric Hacker was given a surprising big league contract and could make the team. Pat Neshek is still in the fold. Scott Diamond – a lefty – is a Rule 5 pick. Alex Burnett, Jeff Manship, Anthony Slama … hard to predict who will all end up here. Did I forget anyone? Eddie Guardado, anyone? I have to believe the Twins will sign a cheap veteran or two to add to this group. Makes my stomach turn just typing the relievers’ names.
  • Everyday lineup: My prediction is CF Denard Span, 2B Tsuyoshi Nishioka, C Joe Mauer, 1B Justin Morneau (assuming he’s ready to go, which is a bit of an assumption), LF Delmon Young, DH Jim Thome, RF Michael Cuddyer, 3B Danny Valencia and SS Alexi Casilla. I really think the Twins are better off bumping Nishioka to the 8 spot and sliding everyone – including Mauer – up a spot. But plenty of studies have shown batting order doesn’t matter much, so it’s not a huge deal.
  • Bench: Jason Kubel ends up here, although he’ll get plenty of playing time. Drew Butera is also a lock to back up Mauer. Jason Repko would also appear to be a safe bet as a defensive replacement in the outfield for the slow-footed Young and Cuddyer. Trevor Plouffe and Matt Tolbert should get good looks as backup infielders, though there’s a good chance there will be only four bench players if the Twins opt to carry 12 relievers. I have to assume they will. Twins manager Ron Gardenhire generally prefers that, and considering the uncertainty in the bullpen, they could probably use the extra arm.

Interesting offseason in the Bronx

Ran across a couple of pretty good stories on ESPN.com regarding the New York Yankees.

The first one is that GM Brian Cashman discouraged the Steinbrenners from signing Rafael Soriano to big bucks to be a set-up man, yet the ownership group did it anyway. The second one is about how the Yankees actually made a contract offer to free-agent pitcher Carl Pavano.

Let’s start with the Soriano deal. The dynamite reliever agreed to a three-year, $35 million contract with the Yankees within the last week. It includes opt-out clauses after each season, which seem unlikely to be exercised by him since he probably isn’t going to get a deal where he would get paid more than that.

Soriano saved 45 games with a 1.73 ERA last season for the Tampa Bay Rays.

The Pavano story is a little more surprising, though I think we can all agree that there’s no way Pavano would have accepted a one-year contract offer like the story says. I’m not sure why the Yankees even bothered with an offer like that, unless they felt Pavano wanted to come back to the Bronx and try and make things right. He was signed to a four-year lucrative offer by the Yankees earlier in his career, but those four injury-plagued years led to the Pavano contract being considered one of the worst in recent history. But he’s bounced back the last year-plus with the Minnesota Twins.

The Twins are expected to have an agreement in place with Pavano by Wednesday.

It’s been a pretty quiet offseason for the Yankees until the Soriano signing. And considering the Boston Red Sox added outfielder Carl Crawford and first baseman Adrian Gonzalez, the AL East seems to have swung in the direction of Beantown.

Don’t expect three that declined arbitration from Twins to return

The deadline for those big leaguers offered arbitration to make a decision came and passed at 11 p.m. Tuesday, and the Minnesota Twins found out that none of their Type A or B free agents offered arbitration will accept it.

Not a huge surprise that starting pitcher Carl Pavano (Type A), infielder Orlando Hudson (Type B) and relief pitcher Jesse Crain (Type B) will try to land long-term, big-dollar deals rather than accept a one-year tender from the Twins.

I also won’t be surprised if none of the three players signs that long-term deal with Minnesota.

The Twins payroll is expected to grow to $125 million this season according to some reports. But that doesn’t mean the organization has a lot of wiggle room to work with. Joe Mauer‘s long-term deal kicks in for 2011, plus the team will no longer be receiving revenue-sharing dollars now that it has a new stadium. There are some constraints.

I don’t think anybody expects to see Hudson back in a Twins uniform, despite having played a pretty solid season last year. But Hudson has been a one-and-done player recently, and he’ll likely continue to search for a two- or three-year deal from some team.

In the case of Pavano, I think the Twins will decide they got a great year and a half from him, and leave it at that. Pavano is considered to be the second-best starter on the free-agent market behind Cliff Lee. And if it’s true that Pavano is looking for a three-year deal when he’ll be 35 years old on Opening Day, I think the Twins are right to let him go, although the challenge becomes, “Who will replace him?”

And with Crain, well, he had to be ecstatic to find out that the Detroit Tigers gave reliever Joaquin Benoit to a three-year, $16.5 million deal. Of course, I’m not saying Crain is in the same class as Benoit, although Crain was great for the Twins last season down the stretch. But I’m sure the Canadian will be hoping for a three-year deal of his own, and I just don’t think that will happen in Minnesota.

No big surprises from Twins’ offseason predictions

Minnesota Twins hoping for a big splash this offseason probably won’t get it.

The Twins have $75 million locked up in nine players with determined salaries for the 2011 season. That doesn’t leave a lot left over for the remaining 16 players.

The writers over at MLBtraderumors.com published their predictions for the top 50 free agents.

The highlights:

  • The majority of writers have the Twins retaining starting pitcher Carl Pavano and designated hitter Jim Thome. But none of the five writers have the Twins keep infielder Orlando Hudson or reliever Brian Fuentes.
  • Other free agents tabbed by the writers to be heading to the Twins this offseason are pitchers Koji Uehara (two writers) and Pedro Feliciano (one writer).
  • All five writers believe the New York Yankees will sign Cliff Lee. I have no doubt in my mind of that happening.
  • All five writers also have the Los Angeles Angels signing outfielder Carl Crawford. I wouldn’t be surprised to see the Detroit Tigers or Boston Red Sox get involved in that bidding war. And you can’t count the Yankees out either.

The anatomy of a lopsided trade

It’s one year to the day that the Minnesota Twins got Carl Pavano in a trade from the Cleveland Indians. And let’s face it, if Twins GM Bill Smith applies for another big league job, this trade will be at the top of his resume.

On Aug. 7, 2009, the Twins acquired Pavano in exchange for minor league pitcher Yohan Pino.

This is what Pavano has done since the trade: 35 starts, 19-11 record, 3.70 ERA.

And the most important stat might be this: Pavano’s average start in that span has lasted 6 2/3 innings.

The guy has been a workhorse since coming over. And considering Pino boasts a 5.87 ERA in 20 starts for Cleveland’s Triple-A team, this was a fleece job.

But the net worth from the Pavano trade doesn’t stop there. The right-hander is a free agent after the season, and it seems unlikely the Twins would retain him (though others may disagree).

Pavano remains in very good position to net the Twins a first-round pick and a compensatory pick should they offer him arbitration after the season and he chooses not to accept. 

Quite a haul for a struggling minor leaguer.

Benefit from Pavano trade could last awhile

I’m the first to admit that I’m stunned how well Carl Pavano has pitched for the Minnesota Twins this season.

The Twins did the right thing in offering him arbitration this past offseason, and Pavano – considering the free-agent market – did the right thing in taking it.

Sporting an epic mustache, Pavano this year has been that steady veteran presence in an otherwise turbulent Twins rotation. He’s gone 9-6 in 15 starts, posting a 3.33 ERA and a .239 opponents’ batting average.

Twins GM Bill Smith probably doesn’t get enough credit for how well last summer’s trade with Cleveland has worked out. The Twins got Pavano from the Indians in exchange for minor league pitcher Yohan Pino. Forget about the Johan trade. It’s the Yohan trade we’re talking about.

Pino, by the way, has a 5.49 ERA in 15 starts for Cleveland’s Triple-A affiliate in Columbus.

But it doesn’t stop there with Pavano, who helped pitch the team to the AL Central title last year.

Pavano is now on pace to be a Type A free agent after the season, according to projections made available by MLBtraderumors.com.

That means his departure after the season would give the Twins a compensatory first-round pick plus the first-round pick of whatever team signs him.

Not a bad haul for Yohan Pino. It might be a better haul for Yohan than it was for Johan.

Winter Meetings recap

Major League Baseball’s Winter Meetings are officially over. Typically, the Winter Meetings are overrated, but this year there was quite a bit of action during the first day or two.

Here’s a look back at the past week:

  • Starting pitcher Carl Pavano decided to accept an arbitration offer from the Minnesota Twins, meaning the veteran right-hander will be back in 2010.
  • The Detroit Tigers, who came within a victory of a division title, were purged significantly. They had already lost second baseman Placido Polanco in free agency, and early in the week, they traded outfielder Curtis Granderson to the New York Yankees and pitcher Edwin Jackson to the Arizona Diamondbacks in a three-team swap.
  • Bad signing of the week: How about Ivan Rodriguez getting a two-year deal to be a catcher for the Washington Nationals? So Pudge makes $1.5 million last year, has the worst season of his career, and the Nats give him a $6 million contract. Makes sense. And this has an Allen Iverson feel to it. The Nats view Pudge as a mentor to youngster Jesus Flores, while he says he expects to be an everyday player.
  • Worst signing of the week: Middle reliever Brandon Lyon gets a three-year, $15 million contract from the Houston Astros. This one’s hard to figure out. Lyon had a nice year last year, but is hardly a dominant reliever. And it’s not like the Astros are one reliever away from making a run.

Finally, I heard on TV today that the Twins plan to watch Cuban defector Aroldis Chapman pitch during a workout in Houston that’s open to major league teams. He’s a left-hander who can hit 100 mph. The Yankees and Boston Red Sox will be there too, and most believe this will be a bidding war between them.

The Yankees and Red Sox presence is scaring many other teams away, leaving most teams thinking they can’t possibly get Chapman’s services.

Here’s a video of Chapman:

 

A couple of morning links

I know for many of you, it’s not exactly morning, or at least not for much longer. But with this journalist’s schedule, anything before 1 p.m. qualifies as morning.

Anyway, here’s a couple of interesting links expanding on Carl Pavano‘s decision to accept arbitration with the Minnesota Twins:

  • Twins blogger Aaron Gleeman writes that Pavano is a worthy gamble for the Twins, and that while his 5.10 ERA for the season doesn’t look appealing, he pitched much better than that. Gleeman says Pavano is not cut from the same cloth as a Ramon Ortiz, Livan Hernandez or Sidney Ponson, and one year of Pavano is much better than multiple seasons of Jarrod Washburn. I couldn’t agree more.
  • Star Tribune writer Joe Christensen on his blog takes a closer look at the team’s payroll, which after arbitration raises looks like it’s already at $90 million for next season. The Twins are pretty hush-hush on what their payroll will be going into the new ballpark, but some have estimated as much as $100 million. Last year, it was $65 million, so this is a substantial bump. And they haven’t even re-signed Joe Mauer yet. So the payroll leaves me wondering how the Twins are going to be able to improve other areas. Look at Christensen’s bench projections. Clearly, the Twins need a veteran or two there. Another infielder – even if it’s Joe Crede – would help too. These aren’t expensive to fill, but a nickel here and a nickel there, and a Mauer extension here and you’re looking at a payroll of $105 million. Would the Twins really go that high? I’ve mentioned before they might have to consider trading Joe Nathan, which would not be a popular move with Mauer.

UPDATE: Twins have designated Boof Bonser for assignment to make room for Pavano. So in all likelihood Bonser won’t be back next year. I assume he can accept an assignment to the minors, but I doubt he would considering the depth of starting pitching the Twins have.

ALSO: Dave Cameron over at FanGraphs praises the Twins’ decision to keep Pavano. He said retaining Pavano and acquiring shortstop J.J. Hardy makes for a good offseason for the Twins.

Pavano deal provides type of contract Twins prefer

Barring a last-minute change of heart, starting pitcher Carl Pavano has decided to accept the arbitration offer from the Minnesota Twins.

Pavano, who went 5-4 with a 4.64 ERA in 12 starts with Minnesota last season after coming over in a trade from Cleveland, reportedly could not find a two-year contract offer from any team, so he elected to take the one-year arbitration offer instead.

Hard to say what Pavano would get an arbitration, though it’s likely the Twins will negotiate a one-year deal with him before he gets there. One estimate I heard on TV today was in the range of $8-10 million for the 2010 season. That’s a lot of dough, but the Twins usually would prefer to pay a lot for one year rather than stretch out less than that for multiple seasons.

Twins GM Bill Smith said earlier this offseason he’d like to have one or two veteran starting pitchers next season. Pavano would provide the Twins with at least one for next season.

Pavano did a nice job for the Twins down the stretch and pitched brilliantly in a playoff loss to the New York Yankees. His presence means the Twins have four of their five rotation spots pretty much nailed down. He’ll join Scott Baker, Nick Blackburn and Kevin Slowey as virtual locks for the 2010 rotation, with Glen Perkins, Brian Duensing, Boof Bonser and Francisco Liriano among those fighting it out for the last spot.

But that’s assuming the Twins don’t make another pitching acquisition. They have been linked to such pitchers as Jarrod Washburn and Rich Harden, but at this point I’d assume Washburn is an unlikely addition because I’m sure he’s seeking a multi-year contract. The Twins – with Pavano – won’t be so deeply in need of a starter that they’d make an offer like that.

Harden, on the other hand, is a much better fit, and with his injury-proned history should garner a one-year deal this offseason.

I’ve said on this blog before that the Twins need an ace. They aren’t going to trade for Roy Halladay or sign John Lackey to a big contract because that’s now how they operate. But adding a free-agent starter like Harden or Erik Bedard or Ben Sheets on a one-year deal would give the Twins someone with ace stuff, assuming that pitcher can stay healthy for the whole season.

  • Harden struck out 171 batters in 141 innings last season for the Chicago Cubs, going 9-9 with a 4.09 ERA in 26 starts. The ERA is not earth-shattering, but he had a 2.55 ERA after the All-Star break and carries a career ERA of 3.39. The Twins reportedly made a waiver claim on him in August, only to have the Cubs pull him back off waivers.
  • Bedard got negative attention in Seattle, partly because he’s injured a lot, and partly because the Mariners gave up a king’s ransom to get him (Adam Jones and George Sherrill among other prospects). Bedard was phenomenal when healthy last season, going 5-3 with a 2.82 ERA in 15 starts before suffering a torn labrum.
  • Sheets has not pitched since 2008, when he went 13-9 with a 3.09 ERA in 31 starts for the Milwaukee Brewers. He was rumored to be considering retirement after his latest season-ending injury, and there’s still a lot of question as to how much he has left to offer.

Sheets and Harden expect to be healthy for Opening Day. Bedard could be out until May or even later, depending on where you get your information.

Pavano definitely does not feel the Twins’ need for an ace, as nicely as he pitched down the stretch last year. But at the very least, his addition should ensure that the Twins don’t make a big mistake in giving a guy like Washburn a multi-year contract when Washburn wouldn’t serve as one either.

Pavano getting headlines, but Twins’ offense is more needed

Prior to the 2005 season, the New York Yankees signed starting pitcher Carl Pavano, hoping the 2003 World Series champion would help bolster their rotation.

Four years and $40 million later, the Yankees and their fans were left feeling cheated.

In reality, it’s the Yankees – not Pavano – who will be looking for revenge when New York tries to eliminate the Minnesota Twins from postseason play on Sunday night.

The Twins send Pavano to the mound hoping to avoid a three-game sweep in the American League Division Series, and hopefully put an end to some pretty disgusting statistics:

  • First off, the Twins have lost eight straight postseason games. Their last win was in Game 1 of the 2004 ALDS against these Yankees, when Johan Santana led the Twins to a 2-0 victory.
  • The Twins have not scored more than three runs in a playoff game since that 2004 series. That’s a streak of five straight games, in which a grand total of 12 runs have been scored.
  • Finally, the Twins have not won a playoff game in which Santana did NOT start in since Game 1 of the 2002 American League Championship Series. Joe Mays did not allow an earned run in eight innings of work, and Eddie Guardado shut the door in a 2-1 Minnesota win.

The one prevailing fact when looking at Twins postseason games in this decade is the lack of runs scored. Yeah, it’s important that Pavano pitches a good game today, but I found myself saying all night on Friday, "Just once, it would be nice to see the Twins bust out for eight runs in a playoff game." Other teams do it. Why can’t they?

Here’s a look at total runs scored by the Twins in each of their playoff series this decade:

  • 2002 ALDS: 27 runs in 5 games (5.40/game)
  • 2002 ALCS: 12 runs in 5 games (2.40/game)
  • 2003 ALDS: 6 runs in 4 games (1.33/game)
  • 2004 ALDS: 17 runs in 4 games (4.25/game)
  • 2006 ALDS: 7 runs in 3 games (2.33/game)
  • 2009 ALDS: 5 runs in 2 games (2.50/game)

The grand total is 74 runs 23 playoff games this decade, an average of 3.21 runs/game. That, obviously, is awful. You’re not going to win many games like that, and the Twins haven’t.

So while it’s important to get a good start from Pavano, it’s much more important the Twins get to veteran Yankees pitcher Andy Pettitte on Sunday.

Pettitte is nothing like previous starters CC Sabathia and A.J. Burnett. Yeah, Pettitte has the ability to make hitters look silly, but not by blowing high fastballs past them.

Power arms burned the Twins in the first two games. The task on Sunday will be to solve "the pitcher’s pitcher," as Bert Blyleven would say.